Field Sobriety Tests in Felony DUI Cases: Validity and Challenges

Field sobriety tests are a fundamental part of DUI cases. These tests are often administered by law enforcement officers during traffic stops to assess whether a driver is impaired. While field sobriety tests are typically used in misdemeanor DUI cases, they also play a crucial role in felony DUI charges. Felony DUI cases usually involve more severe circumstances, such as repeat offenses, accidents resulting in serious injuries, or DUI charges involving minors. The results of field sobriety tests can heavily influence the trajectory of a felony DUI case. However, the validity of these tests is frequently contested, and defendants often challenge the outcomes in court. Understanding the purpose, methodology, and inherent challenges of field sobriety tests is critical for both the accused and the prosecution.

BadAss Attorney

Best DUI Lawyers

DUI Defense Lawyers - Board of Directors

10 Consecutive Years Selected to Super Lawyers

Best Lawyers In America

AV Prememinent

AVVO 10

AVVO Client's Choice

AVVO

Best Lawyers Best Law Firms

The Role of Field Sobriety Tests in Felony DUI Cases

Field sobriety tests are designed to help law enforcement determine whether a driver is under the influence of alcohol or drugs. Officers typically administer these tests on the side of the road during a traffic stop. The purpose is to observe the driver’s physical coordination, balance, and ability to follow instructions. While there are many different field sobriety tests, the three standardized tests approved by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) are the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) test, the Walk-and-Turn test, and the One-Leg Stand test. These tests are intended to measure impairment by testing a driver’s eye movements, ability to walk in a straight line, and balance on one leg.

In felony DUI cases, field sobriety tests are often used as preliminary evidence of impairment. Law enforcement relies on these tests to justify further testing, such as breath or blood tests, which can measure blood alcohol concentration (BAC) levels more definitively. However, because felony DUI cases involve more severe consequences, the scrutiny on the validity and reliability of field sobriety tests is often heightened. Any inaccuracies in the administration of these tests can have significant implications for the outcome of the case.

Validity of Field Sobriety Tests

The validity of field sobriety tests is a frequent point of contention in felony DUI cases. While these tests are widely used, their scientific reliability has been questioned by legal professionals and researchers alike. The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) test, for example, involves observing the involuntary jerking of the eyes as they follow a moving object. This test is based on the premise that alcohol consumption can exaggerate this jerking motion, making it more noticeable. However, other factors such as fatigue, certain medications, and even natural eye conditions can also cause similar movements. This raises concerns about the reliability of the HGN test in accurately measuring alcohol impairment.

Greg Willis has been successful at defending DUI cases (over 93% without a conviction)

He's the only lawyer in the State of Georgia to ever be recognized for all three of these accomplishments.

Received the Samurai Lawyer Award for having gone to jail for a total of 4 days in order to save his own client

Received the BadAss Lawyer Award for the biggest impact of all DUI lawyers in DUI defense in the country

Received the vote of Georgia Lawyers as a Superlawyer in DUI Law for 10 straight consecutive years

 

Similarly, the Walk-and-Turn and One-Leg Stand tests rely heavily on physical coordination and balance. These tests assume that impaired drivers will struggle to walk in a straight line or balance on one leg. However, numerous external factors can affect a person’s performance on these tests. For instance, nervousness, uneven road surfaces, weather conditions, and pre-existing medical conditions such as arthritis or vertigo can impact the results. In felony DUI cases, where the stakes are particularly high, defendants often challenge the validity of field sobriety test results by arguing that their performance was influenced by factors other than alcohol impairment.

Challenges to Field Sobriety Tests in Court

Defendants in felony DUI cases frequently challenge the results of field sobriety tests. These challenges often focus on the circumstances under which the tests were administered, the officer’s training and experience, and the individual’s unique physical or medical condition. One of the most common challenges is the argument that the tests were improperly administered. Officers must follow strict guidelines when conducting field sobriety tests, and any deviation from these protocols can compromise the accuracy of the results. For example, if an officer fails to provide clear instructions or administers the tests on an uneven surface, the results may be skewed.

Additionally, defendants may argue that the officer conducting the field sobriety tests lacked sufficient training or experience. Law enforcement officers are trained to administer these tests according to NHTSA guidelines, but human error can occur. In some cases, officers may misinterpret a driver’s performance, especially in stressful or high-pressure situations. Defense attorneys often scrutinize the officer’s training records and the conditions of the traffic stop to determine whether the field sobriety tests were administered correctly.

Another common challenge in felony DUI cases involves the defendant’s physical or medical condition. Defendants may argue that their poor performance on the tests was due to a condition unrelated to alcohol impairment. For example, individuals with leg injuries, balance disorders, or neurological conditions may struggle to perform the Walk-and-Turn or One-Leg Stand tests, even if they are not impaired by alcohol. Medical records and testimony can be used to support these claims and undermine the validity of the field sobriety test results.

Greg has truly mastered his craft. His preparation is second to none and his confidence helps reduce the nervousness and anxiety his clients face. He is a real life version of Harvey Specter and I highly recommend him.”

- Travis

Greg and his team are absolutely incredible. Greg explained everything to me in detail, as this is the first ever time I have been arrested. Regular updates throughout the process which allowed me to get on with everyday life. 200% I would recommend Greg and his team to anyone with a DUI case."

- James Hellens

Mr Willis is the best in the business. He knows the law inside and out. I was in a serious jam and Greg got my dui reduced to a reckless driving. This man will fight for you every step of the way."

- Anonymous

The Impact of Field Sobriety Test Results on Felony DUI Cases

The results of field sobriety tests can significantly impact the outcome of a felony DUI case. Positive test results, where the driver appears to be impaired, often lead to further testing and can be used as evidence to support a DUI charge. In felony cases, where the consequences are more severe, such as longer prison sentences and higher fines, the prosecution relies heavily on field sobriety test results to establish impairment. However, because the validity of these tests is frequently challenged, the outcome of a felony DUI case can hinge on whether the court accepts or rejects the field sobriety test results as reliable evidence.

Judges and juries are often swayed by the credibility of the field sobriety tests, but defense attorneys can cast doubt on this evidence by highlighting the tests’ inherent flaws and questioning the officer’s conduct during the traffic stop. The impact of field sobriety test results on a felony DUI case ultimately depends on the effectiveness of the arguments presented by both the prosecution and the defense.

Defending Against Field Sobriety Test Results in Felony DUI Cases

Defendants in felony DUI cases have several options when it comes to defending against field sobriety test results. One common defense strategy is to file a motion to suppress the evidence obtained from the tests. This can be done if the defense can prove that the tests were improperly administered or that the officer lacked reasonable suspicion to stop the driver in the first place. If the court grants the motion, the results of the field sobriety tests may be excluded from the trial, weakening the prosecution’s case.

Another defense strategy is to challenge the credibility of the field sobriety tests themselves. By presenting evidence that the tests are not scientifically valid or that they are prone to error, the defense can undermine the prosecution’s reliance on the test results. This may involve calling into question the officer’s training, the conditions under which the tests were administered, or the defendant’s unique physical or medical condition. Successfully challenging the field sobriety test results can create reasonable doubt in the minds of the jury, leading to a more favorable outcome for the defendant.

Related Videos

The Role of Legal Representation in Felony DUI Cases Involving Field Sobriety Tests

Given the high stakes in felony DUI cases, it is essential for defendants to have strong legal representation. An experienced attorney can help defendants navigate the complexities of field sobriety tests and build a solid defense strategy. A skilled attorney will scrutinize every aspect of the traffic stop, from the officer’s initial decision to pull the driver over to the administration of the field sobriety tests. By carefully examining the evidence and challenging the validity of the tests, an attorney can help defendants fight back against felony DUI charges.

Legal representation is especially critical in cases where the results of field sobriety tests are being contested. Attorneys with experience in DUI defense understand the nuances of field sobriety tests and the many factors that can influence the results. They are adept at questioning the prosecution’s evidence and presenting alternative explanations for the defendant’s performance on the tests. With the right legal strategy, defendants can challenge the field sobriety test results and work towards a more favorable outcome in their felony DUI case.

If you or someone you know is facing felony DUI charges involving field sobriety tests, it is crucial to seek legal representation as soon as possible. The consequences of a felony DUI conviction can be severe, and you need an experienced attorney to guide you through the legal process. At Willis Law Firm, we have the knowledge and resources to challenge the validity of field sobriety tests and build a strong defense on your behalf. Contact our firm today for a consultation and let us help you protect your rights and your future.