Evidence Needed for DUI Convictions and How to Challenge It

Welcome to Willis Law Firm’s blog, where we navigate the intricate landscape of DUI defense in Georgia. We understand the gravity of the charges our clients face, and the complexities involved in mounting a strong defense, and in this post, we delve into a crucial aspect of cases: the evidence needed for DUI convictions.

DUI covictions hinge heavily on the evidence presented by the prosecution. Understanding the types of evidence that can be used against you is paramount in crafting a strategic defense. From field sobriety tests to breathalyzer results, each piece of evidence carries its own significance and potential for challenge.

Join us as we dissect the various forms of evidence needed for DUI convictions, explore their reliability, and discuss effective defense strategies to counter them. When you’re facing your first DUI charge or navigating a complex legal situation, knowledge is your greatest asset. 

BadAss Attorney

Best DUI Lawyers

DUI Defense Lawyers - Board of Directors

10 Consecutive Years Selected to Super Lawyers

Best Lawyers In America

AV Prememinent

AVVO 10

AVVO Client's Choice

AVVO

Best Lawyers Best Law Firms

What is a DUI?

In Georgia, DUI is defined as operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol, drugs, or a combination of both to the extent that it impairs the driver’s ability to safely operate the vehicle. This definition encompasses a broad range of scenarios, from driving with a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) above the legal limit to driving while impaired by prescription or illegal drugs.

One of the key elements of a DUI offense in Georgia is the concept of “less safe” driving. This means that a person can be charged with DUI even if their BAC is below the legal limit of 0.08%. If law enforcement officers determine that a driver’s ability to operate a vehicle safely is impaired due to alcohol or drugs, they can still be arrested and charged with DUI.

In addition to alcohol, Georgia law prohibits driving under the influence of drugs, including prescription medications and illegal substances. This includes both illicit drugs like marijuana, cocaine, and methamphetamine, as well as prescription medications that can impair driving ability, such as painkillers and sedatives. It’s essential for individuals to be aware that even if a drug is legally prescribed, driving while under its influence can still lead to a DUI charge.

Penalties for DUI convictions in Georgia are severe and can vary depending on factors such as prior offenses, BAC level, and whether there were any aggravating circumstances, such as accidents or injuries. Typical penalties for a first-time DUI offense may include fines, license suspension, mandatory alcohol or drug education programs, community service, and even jail time. Subsequent offenses carry even harsher penalties, including longer license suspensions, higher fines, and mandatory jail sentences.

As DUI defense attorneys, our role is to vigorously defend individuals accused of DUI and protect their rights throughout the legal process. This may involve challenging the validity of field sobriety tests, questioning the accuracy of breathalyzer or blood test results, and identifying any procedural errors or constitutional violations that occurred during the arrest.

Greg has truly mastered his craft. His preparation is second to none and his confidence helps reduce the nervousness and anxiety his clients face. He is a real life version of Harvey Specter and I highly recommend him.”

- Travis

Greg and his team are absolutely incredible. Greg explained everything to me in detail, as this is the first ever time I have been arrested. Regular updates throughout the process which allowed me to get on with everyday life. 200% I would recommend Greg and his team to anyone with a DUI case."

- James Hellens

Mr Willis is the best in the business. He knows the law inside and out. I was in a serious jam and Greg got my dui reduced to a reckless driving. This man will fight for you every step of the way."

- Anonymous

Evidence Needed for DUI Convictions

In a DUI case, the prosecution’s success hinges on the evidence they present. Here’s a breakdown of the types of evidence crucial for securing DUI convictions in Georgia.

Law enforcement officers’ observations play a pivotal role. Their testimony about a driver’s behavior leading up to and during the traffic stop such as erratic driving, swerving, or speeding forms the basis for establishing probable cause and initiating a DUI investigation.

Field sobriety tests (FSTs) are another cornerstone of DUI cases. These tests, like the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) test or the Walk-and-Turn test, evaluate a driver’s physical coordination and mental clarity. The results, as interpreted by the arresting officer, serve as evidence of impairment.

Breathalyzer or chemical tests are commonly administered to measure a driver’s blood alcohol concentration (BAC) or detect drug presence. While breathalyzer tests are frequent, they are not foolproof and can be prone to errors.

For more accurate BAC measurements and drug detection, blood tests are conducted. However, these tests can also face challenges like mishandling of samples or contamination, affecting their reliability.

Eyewitness testimony from passengers or other drivers may also come into play. Their accounts can either support or challenge the narrative presented by law enforcement.

Video evidence from dashcams or body cameras provides crucial insights. It captures the entire interaction, from the driver’s behavior to their performance on FSTs, helping to uncover any inconsistencies in the prosecution’s case.

Each of these pieces of evidence contributes to the overall narrative in a DUI case, shaping its outcome significantly.

Greg Willis has been successful at defending DUI cases (over 93% without a conviction)

He's the only lawyer in the State of Georgia to ever be recognized for all three of these accomplishments.

Received the Samurai Lawyer Award for having gone to jail for a total of 4 days in order to save his own client

Received the BadAss Lawyer Award for the biggest impact of all DUI lawyers in DUI defense in the country

Received the vote of Georgia Lawyers as a Superlawyer in DUI Law for 10 straight consecutive years

 

 

Challenging the Evidence

Here are some common strategies used to effectively challenge the forms of evidence commonly used for DUI conviction in Georgia.

Field Sobriety Tests (FSTs)

Field sobriety tests (FSTs) pose challenges in their administration. They are standardized, but adherence to strict protocols during their execution is crucial. Any deviations from these protocols can compromise the validity of the test results. For instance, if an officer fails to properly demonstrate or explain the test instructions, it can significantly affect the accuracy of the driver’s performance.

Moreover, the subjectivity inherent in FSTs is a point of contention. These tests rely on the arresting officer’s subjective interpretation, making them susceptible to bias and error. External factors such as weather conditions, uneven terrain, or the driver’s physical limitations can unfairly influence the test results. By highlighting these variables, doubts can be cast on the reliability of FSTs as evidence of impairment.

Breathalyzer or Chemical Tests

Breathalyzer or chemical tests are commonly used to gauge a driver’s blood alcohol concentration (BAC), yet their reliability isn’t absolute. The accuracy of breathalyzer machines hinges on meticulous calibration and maintenance protocols. Scrutinizing maintenance records, calibration logs, and the operator’s qualifications allows us to contest the trustworthiness of breathalyzer evidence.

The validity of breathalyzer outcomes can be compromised by several variables, such as mouth alcohol presence, lingering substances, or medical conditions like acid reflux. These elements can trigger false positives and inaccuracies in BAC measurements. Thoroughly examining the circumstances surrounding the breath test empowers us to pinpoint potential error sources and dispute the legitimacy of the results.

Blood Test Results

We carefully examine blood test results to ensure their accuracy and reliability. This involves checking the chain of custody, which encompasses the proper collection, storage, and analysis of blood samples to maintain their integrity as evidence. Any lapses in this process could raise doubts about the trustworthiness of the results. We also question the accuracy of the analysis itself, as errors can occur if the tests are not conducted correctly or if the samples become contaminated. Working alongside independent experts, we review the forensic analysis to identify any discrepancies or irregularities in the testing process. By challenging the scientific validity of the blood test results, we aim to undermine their credibility in legal proceedings.

Additionally, we evaluate witness testimony to ensure its reliability. Eyewitness accounts can be subjective and influenced by various factors such as bias, memory distortion, or external pressure. Through thorough cross-examination, we strive to uncover inconsistencies or contradictions in witness testimonies, weakening the prosecution’s case against our client by questioning the credibility of the witnesses.

Video Evidence

When examining video evidence, we aim to question its interpretation. For instance, footage of a DUI arrest might not always present a straightforward narrative. Our focus lies in carefully analyzing the video to pinpoint any differences between what’s shown and what the arresting officer recounts. These disparities or uncertainties in the video can serve as tools to challenge the prosecution’s narrative and raise doubts about the events as presented.

Featured Case Results

An Advocate for You

Navigating and negating the evidence needed for DUI convictions in Georgia is a complex and challenging endeavor. But from field sobriety tests to chemical analyses, each piece of evidence presents its own opportunities for challenge and scrutiny. As experienced DUI defense attorneys at Willis Law Firm, we understand the gravity of facing DUI charges and the importance of mounting a strong defense against them.

If you or someone you know is facing DUI charges in Georgia, it’s crucial to seek knowledgeable legal representation as soon as possible. Our team at Willis Law Firm has the experience and dedication to effectively challenge the prosecution’s evidence and advocate for your rights throughout the legal process.

Don’t face DUI charges alone. Contact Willis Law Firm today to schedule a consultation and discuss your case with a Georgia DUI defense attorney. Together, we can work towards achieving the best possible outcome and protecting your future.

Related Videos